Jacki: James Madison

James Madison, by Garry Wills

I know that this sounds kind of lame, but when I chose a biography to read about James Madison, I chose by length.  There were only a few that were even out there.  There were two that had pretty good reviews: this one (at about 200 pages) and a big old, huge 700 page one.  While I’m interested in ol’ James Madison I wasn’t really ready to read 700 pages so I ended up with this one.

I am oh so glad.

While this was short, it really did pack a punch.  From the get-go the author said that the general view of James Madison is that he was a great politician and a great man but really not a great president.  His goal with this book was to really lay out why that was.  Because of this goal, the whole book just tied together so well.  Every bit of info that Garry Wills shared about James Madison supported this fact.  This led to a real cohesiveness that made this kind of scholarly book really readable.

That being said, this book was kind of boring.  James Madison is just sort of dull.  Even the War of 1812? Kind of boring.  How can a WAR be boring?! But it really was.  A lot of the book was dedicated to Madison’s politics and how they shaped his presidency.  To be perfectly honest, I’m not a super political person and I would have rather read more about his marriage or about his home life.  Ya know?  That isn’t really a knock against this book, but it’s just a personal preference.

Learning how much influence James Madison had on the Constitution was a little bit overwhelming.  It’s incredible that someone that we know so little about is still shaping our country in so many ways is just kind of crazy.  Even though there were all these low points in his presidency, seeing just what he did for our country is enough to kind of leave you in awe.

I do wish that there had been a little bit more about James Madison’s personal life, but outside of that I was really happy with this book.  It was written is a scholarly but readable way.  I would recommend this to anyone who wants to know more about one of our most prominent founding fathers but doesn’t want to dedicate a full week to reading about him.

Orignal Post


Jessica: Martin Van Buren

Martin Van Buren and the American Political System, by Donald Cole

As much as this biography was written in a very academic format there were times when I just couldn’t put it down (strange right)? Maybe it was the fact that going into this book I only knew two things about Martin Van Buren, the first being his name, and the second was that he was the 8th president of the US. Fairly obvious but I do believe that is what 99% of the population know about Van Buren as well.

Sure Van Buren wasn’t a memorable president. He didn’t have the stature of Washington, the speaking ability of John Adams, he wasn’t as debonaire as Jefferson, and he certainly didn’t have the temper or hot-headedness of Jackson, but he did posess an ability to “puppet master” the best of them and earned himself the nickname of “Little Magician”.

Van Buren was a master at looking at an issue without a strong opinion one way or the other and then crafting his stance on the issue in a way to use it to his ability to succeed. Although he straddled the fence on many important issues at the time, he was a firm believer in a two-party system and fought for the same throughout his political career.

In my opinion Van Buren was the first president to take office that was a true politician and was able to manipulate the system and the public. He is the first president that I have read about who reminds me of the politicians of today.

Orignal Post

Julie: John Adams

John Adams, by David McCullough

I am such a fan of John Adams now.  If you had asked me two months ago how I felt about John Adams I would have had no idea how to answer you.  But through reading this book I learned so much about him as a historical figure and as a person.  I feel like he and Abigail are my friends.  The sad thing about historical biographies is that you know how it’s going to end – all of the main characters are going to die.  Did you know that John Adams and Thomas Jefferson died on the same day?  July 4th, on the 50th anniversary of the signing of the Declaration of Independence.
There is so much to this book that giving a quick summary isn’t going to work, so I’m going to highlight four things that I found particularly inspiring from my new friend John.
John Adams strongly opposed a two party system of government.  He wrote, “There is nothing I dread so much as a division of the Republic into two parties, each arranged under its leader and converting measures in opposition to each other.”  I read this part the Friday night that the whole government shutdown seemed as if it would go into affect and it struck me as so prescient.  How applicable to our own political climate and particularly to the inability for Congress to come together across party lines for the good of the people that we’ve recently seen!
More of a personal significance to this one: John Adams found exercise, in particular daily walks, to be essential to his mental and physica health.  When his son complained of feeling lethargic, John wrote to him “Move or die is the language of our Maker in the consitution of our bodies…When you cannot walk abroad, walk in your room.”  And it’s not just something he said – as we follow him across Europe and through various diplomatic situations and ultimately the Presidency and old age, he continued to spend a portion of each day outside getting exercise.  So when my alarm goes off at 6:30 for me to go walk, I’ve been saying to myself “Move or die!” as I’m tempted to hit snooze.
As we come to an election year I find this quote to be very timely: “I think instead of opposing systematically any administration, running down their characters and opposing all their measures, right or wrong, we ought to support every administration as far as we can in justice.”  Like I mentioned earlier, Adams did not believe in a two party system, and, because of that, was villified in the press both by the Federalists and the Republicans.  When he ran against Jefferson after his first term, Jefferson used whatever means he could to diminish Adams as a rival – but Adams never publically criticized a political opponent.  Can you guys imagine how much easier an election year would be if the candidates didn’t publically criticize their opponents?  We might actually know where they stand on the issues and be able to have an informed vote!  Crazy!
My last quote relates to John Adams’ spiritual life.  One thing I greatly appreciated about this author is that he presents Adams’ religion in an unbiased way and doesn’t attempt to downplay or emphasize it.  He writes about where appropriate and it is very clear that, while Adams wasn’t perfect, he was a man who loved God and wanted to serve him.  This quote, from a letter written to Jefferson at the end of both of their lives, describes how Adams feels about what gives life meaning: “I believe in God and in his wisdom and benevolence, and I cannot believe that such a Being could make such a species as the human merely to live and die on this earth.  If I did not believe in a future state, I should believe in no God.  This universe, this all, this totality [Adams writes in Greek here, but it translates to “totality”] would appear with all its swelling pomp, a boyish firework.”  This from the man known as the “voice” of the Declaration of Independance.  At the end of his life, all he had accomplished was but “swelling pomp” without the knowledge of a life yet to come.  And personally, John and Abigail Adams are at the top of my list of people I want to meet in that afterlife.
This is getting very long, so let me quickly address the writing and entertainment value and then I’ll be done.
Excellent.  Not a single flaw or criticism to be made.  The author did his research, supports his research with fact, and cites his sources extensively.  In addition, he brings the characters to life in a way that leads the reader to care for them as people.  I will definitely be reading more by this author.  He has a new fan in me.
It’s a historical biography, which is to say that, like George Washington, you probably won’t find this along the same vein as a suspense novel.  BUT that is not to say that you won’t find it infinitely fascinating.  There were nights when I literally could not stop reading.  I felt on the edge of my seat, even though I knew what would happen next.  The author is that good and the story itself is that good.  If you are at all interesting in knowing the history of our country, this is a great place to start.
Final Words: I recommend it to anyone.  Seriously.  Even if you are not a history buff and don’t typically read biography, I think you may find this different than what you’ve experienced before.  Loved it, loved John, loved Abigail, and I can’t wait to get my hands on their letters to each other.